• Font Size    
Other CBS4 Blogs
Karen Leigh Vic Lombardi Dominic Dezzutti Vic Lombardi's Signature Greg Moody Greg Moody's Cycling Blog
About Dr. Dave's Blog
Dr. Dave Hnida is CBS4's medical editor. He writes in his blog about both medical issues and military issues (Hnida is a also major in the Army and has served in Iraq).
 Read Hnida's Bio
Oct 21, 2009 4:30 PM

TO SCREEN OR NOT TO SCREEN

Posted by Dr. Dave Hnida

Interesting stuff from the American Cancer Society when it comes to cancer screenings. It seems the society is taking a new, and perhaps, more realistic look at the benefits of screening.

"The advantages of screening have been overstated." So says the head of the ACS, Dr. Otis Brawley.

It makes you wonder what exactly that means, and what we should be doing to find cancer early.

At the bottom of the page is a link to the original article, which appeared in the New York Times.

I think the gist of this whole thing is the benefits of screening for prostate and breast cancer are not as great as we've been hearing. But when it comes to screening for colon cancer or melanoma, the benefits seems clear.

Its a tough message. But I do worry people will get the wrong message, that is, cancer screenings may be a waste of time. Thats not so.

When it comes to breast cancer, stick to the recommended schedule for screening. I do think, however, prostate cancer screenings need to be recommended on an individual basis- in other words, one size may not fit all. We'll see where this one lands.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/21/health/21cancer.html?_r=1&hpw

 

Comments (1)

  • Oct-22 - P B What about full body scans, do they fall int to the same category of promising more than they can deliver?

    Become A Web Programmer Learn Asp.Net
    ...  Show Full Comment
About Dr. Dave's Blog
Dr. Dave Hnida is CBS4's medical editor. He writes in his blog about both medical issues and military issues (Hnida is a also major in the Army and has served in Iraq).
 Read Hnida's Bio
Other CBS4 Blogs
Karen Leigh Vic Lombardi Dominic Dezzutti Vic Lombardi's Signature Greg Moody Greg Moody's Cycling Blog
Advertisement
Search this Blog
Search
Poll
WHAT IS THE MOST HORRIFYING BODY PART?





Suggested Links
Calendar
«November 2009»
SMTWTFS
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293012345
Subscribe to this blog
Dr. Dave Hnida's Blog RSS Feed Subscribe to Recent RSS Updates